IBS, Magnetron Sputtering or ALD? What the 2026 Coating Roadmap Means for Absorption and LIDT

High-Power Laser and Beam Delivery · 2026-09-24 · 3 min read

Every optical coating argument eventually collapses into one question: how much energy does the film absorb, and how long does it survive doing so? The deposition method is the single largest lever on both answers, which is why the process discussion has moved from the coating lab into purchasing meetings.

IBS, Magnetron Sputtering or ALD? What the 2026 Coating Roadmap Means for Absorption and LIDT

Here is the working comparison, stripped of vendor language.

Electron-beam evaporation with ion assistance

The workhorse. Wide material choice, large chambers, moderate cost per part, and good uniformity over big substrates. Ion assistance raises packing density considerably compared with plain evaporation, which reduces moisture shift and improves durability. The limit is microstructure: columns and residual porosity survive, and porosity is where absorption and laser damage begin. For imaging optics, filters and general-purpose mirrors this remains the right process. For multi-kilowatt laser duty it is usually the wrong one.

Magnetron sputtering

Dense films, good adhesion, excellent run-to-run stability, and a natural fit for high-volume production of AR coatings, IR-cut filters and display cover glass. Sputtering handles oxide multilayers well and scales laterally, which matters when the part is a 300 mm panel rather than a 12 mm mirror. The trade-off is target cost and the difficulty of some high-index materials; it also tends to produce slightly higher stress in thick stacks.

Ion-beam sputtering (IBS)

The reference process for high-power and ultrafast laser optics. IBS films are amorphous and dense, with absorption that can sit in the low parts-per-million range, and interface roughness low enough to keep scatter down. That combination is what allows a mirror to hold reflectivity under thermal load instead of drifting. IBS also supports precise dispersion control, which is why femtosecond mirror designs are almost always IBS. The costs are real: slow deposition, limited substrate size, and a price per part several times that of e-beam.

Atomic layer deposition (ALD)

The newest entrant to production optics. ALD builds films one self-limiting monolayer at a time, so thickness control reaches the sub-nanometre level and conformality over structured surfaces is excellent. For precision bandpass filters, bonded wafers and metasurface encapsulation it solves problems the other three cannot. It is also slow in absolute terms, which is why current adoption concentrates on thin critical layers and on designs where uniformity across a large aperture is the governing spec, rather than on thick quarter-wave stacks.

The 2026 pattern

The interesting shift is not that one process is replacing another. It is that designs are being split: ALD for the layers that set centring accuracy, IBS for the layers that carry the energy, magnetron for the layers that must be cheap and uniform over a large area, e-beam for everything where the specification is comfortable. Coating houses that can mix processes in one supply chain are winning specifications that a single-process shop has to decline.

What to ask when you specify

  • State the absorption budget, not only the reflectivity target.
  • State the LIDT test conditions you will accept — wavelength, pulse duration, repetition rate, beam diameter, test standard.
  • Say whether the substrate will see a large temperature swing; that decides whether moisture shift matters.
  • For large apertures, ask for the uniformity map, not a single point measurement.
  • For ultrafast, ask for GDD and for the measurement method.

A coating process is not a brand preference. It is a set of physical limits, and the cheapest way to buy the wrong one is to specify only the number that appears on the front of the datasheet.

← All 400 articles

Need a Quote or Engineering Review?

Send your drawings, specifications or coating requirements — we reply within 24 hours.

Request a Quote

Related Articles

Request a Quote